Today I visited the
local fish market and was surprised to hear fisherwoman bargaining in English
using words like “fresh”, “expensive” and “twelve hundred.” Yet, nearly a month
ago, I saw several participants getting punished for using English phrases during
day-to-day conversations in India’s premier reality show, Big Boss. Why is this
anti-English idea being mooted on popular television shows when most of the
world has adopted the language as their own and the world has gone truly
global? Are TV show producers steadily succumbing to the paranoia of the
medieval mindsets.
And, by the way, what
is a medieval mindset? In the period following the collapse of the Roman Empire
from the 5th century right up to the sixteenth century religion
ruled the roost. All the major religions of the world came into prominence
during this period but culture declined. The followers of these modern
religions were just as brutal and barbaric as their pagan counterparts. The
Christian armies burnt and even ate the corpses of their foes during the
crusades at the start of the previous millennium.
The Renaissance in
the 15th and 16th century came as a breath of fresh air
to the sea of unenlightened humanity who just could not look out of the box
they had so ‘religiously’ prepared and entrapped themselves in. But the
medieval mindset continued on and has survived even up to this day of tablets, Smartphones,
iPods and YouTube videos.
Unfortunately,
fascists as in Egypt and possibly in India as well, the chief proponents of
this medieval mindset, are being elected to power all over the world. We can
ignore this threat to our own peril. People accept them as a means of change from
all that is not right with their present systems, but they could be in for a
rude shock when the change does happen!
Vivek - English language and Indian's command of it clearly have given it an edge in the services sector over and above emerging countries like China etc and gainfully employed a fairly notable size of the population. However i also think that we get over zealous about English. Even in a country like UK the schools teach French, Spanish, German, Latin etc. That is because these are some of the other major languages spoken outside of English. Albeit a language like Chinese is catching up.
ReplyDeleteMy view is without forgetting our own language we should master other languages in the world so that when one travels (and that is almost inevitable in a Global Marketplace) you are not restricted to Bonjour and Merci like yours faithfully :-)
Nice point, Soumyaroop.
ReplyDeleteHowever I just want to clarify that I'm not against learning and promotion of other languages. It would have been great if Big Boss rewarded participants for speaking in Urdu, Sanskrit, Mandarin or Russian, but they shouldn't have punished participants for speaking in English as it sends out a negative signal to the next generation that English is not good for us. Hindi, Sanskrit, Urdu and English have helped unite the country in more ways than one and each of them should be given due respect.
ReplyDeleteAgree. I realized what a fool I was that I did not learn more languages when I was in school
ReplyDeleteAgree. I realized what a fool I was that I did not learn more languages when I was in school
ReplyDeleteI'm sorry I did not mention Bengali as the early freedom fighters like Rabindranath Tagore did a lot to unite India through that tongue. I still remember learning "mishti dohi" at your home.
ReplyDeleteBengali rocks!
ReplyDeleteYes, even I adore Tagore and all the Bengali poets. Nice chaps.
ReplyDelete